Monthly Archives: February 2025

Looking Through A Spyglass

When I was five or six I came into the possession of a spyglass..  It wasn’t the real thing, just a plastic toy with plastic lenses. It may have come from a Halloween pirate costume, but its origin is ultimately wrapped in the vicissitudes of time. I do remember looking through it and being amazed. The magnification was laughably low, but it did work.  I could see things up close that were far away. What a concept!

With that spyglass, I could peer more deeply into my world. I could look out the window at the trees and the front yard. I could use it to stare at the tv screen and wonder why it looked so strange (now I know I was looking at pixels…). I couldn’t get enough of the thing.

One day, I picked up the spyglass and inadvertently looked through the wrong end. What? Everything looked so far away! I remember being utterly confounded. The same device that pulled things closer now pushed them so far away. I now know that wasn’t magic, just physics. But at the time, it laid out an existential dilemma: how can one thing offer two opposite perspectives in the same form?

Maybe I didn’t phrase it that way, but the confrontation with reality was real: I remember holding that spyglass and thinking – hard! – about this tangible example of duality. It hadn’t yet occurred to me that I – or anyone – could hold multiple truths, contradictory emotions, and values.

Recalling this moment in my young life, it occurred to me that being Jewish is like owning a spyglass. Sometimes, we look through the small lens, and we immediately see what must be done. We Jews are a people of the present tense. We see what needs to get done, so we rise up and do it. In such times we understand that life mandates we focus on the here and now.

But then sometimes we look through the larger objective lens, and everything is miniaturized, distant, and vast. In that moment, we are not seeing anything up close. Instead, we have an utterly aspirational vision. We look into the distance and imagine what is yet possible. It is a messianic perspective.

Our tradition is like a spiritual spyglass through which to espy the world. And what I’m seeing through the small lens is overwhelming. This country that I love is abandoning the poor and hungry of the world who depend on us. Policy decisions are being made that endanger the health of us all. Our allies are being cast out the service entrance as undesirables while an enemy is being greeted at the front door.

I am feeling overcome and undone. I cast my eyes to the mountain through the spyglass, and I don’t see where my help will come from.  It feels confusing and overwhelming. I don’t have the ability to respond in a meaningful way. The darkness and fear I feel, as do so many immigrants and federal workers is almost incapacitating.  

These concerns are not liberal or conservative, left or right. They are legitimate Jewish responses to the world today. I don’t think it is possible to contribute to the present moment in any meaningful way while being wholly engulfed by it. We need to take some time to regain our perspective. We need to take a moment and look through the larger end of the spyglass with a Jewish eye and regain our sense of perspective that in the larger world, a bigger promise awaits us.

And then—with renewed clarity and purpose—we turn the spyglass again. We cast our Jewish eye upon the immediate world, bringing into sharp focus what must be done here and now. We see the hands that need holding, the voices that need amplifying, the wrongs that need righting. And then, grounded in both eternal vision and present duty, we get to work.

A poem lovely as a tree…

We are surrounded by extraordinary phenomena. Miles beneath our feet lies Earth’s core, whose exact composition, temperature, and gravitational intensity are still shrouded in mystery. Above us stretches a sky that opens to the cosmos, filled with remarkable celestial objects. And all of it—all of us—is permeated by dark matter, a mysterious force that physicists deem essential to understanding the Universe, though we haven’t yet proven its existence.

These massive forces that push us into realms of the unfathomable captivate me. My love for cosmology, astronomy, and astrophysics, coupled with an equal fascination for paleoanthropology and neurology, connects to a deep appreciation for the divine and endless gratitude for both my individual life and Life itself.

This brings me to today’s holiday, Tu Bishvat, the birthday of the trees. Those who grew up with even a tangential relationship to a synagogue remember Tu Bishvat – receiving that little blue pushke to fill with coins for the JNF, perhaps participating in a Tu Bishvat seder with its traditional fruits from Israel, like figs, dates, grapes, olives, and pomegranates, along with fruits we haven’t tasted in a long time.

But there’s something profound about this day, which began as a simple agricultural marker for dating when tree fruits could be eaten. It’s about the trees themselves – their essence and meaning. As Richard Powers writes in The Overstory, “No one sees trees. We see fruit, we see nuts, we see wood, we see shade. We see ornaments or pretty fall foliage. Obstacles blocking the road or wrecking the ski slope. Dark, threatening places that must be cleared. We see branches about to crush our roof. We see a cash crop. But trees – trees are invisible.”

Even now, in the depths of winter, these seemingly lifeless giants are carrying out remarkable processes. New England’s trees have evolved sophisticated survival strategies. Deciduous trees begin winter preparation as autumn approaches, gradually halting photosynthesis. The breakdown of chlorophyll reveals the hidden yellows and reds we call fall foliage. At a cellular level, they’re performing complex chemical transformations, producing natural antifreeze compounds that protect their cells from freezing damage.

What appears to be a bare, dormant maple is actually a thriving organism, temporarily conserving energy by living off stored reserves in its roots and inner bark. But perhaps most remarkable is our deep connection to these ancient beings. As Powers notes, “You and the tree in your backyard come from a common ancestor. A billion and a half years ago, the two of you parted ways. But even now, after an immense journey in separate directions, that tree and you still share a quarter of your genes…”

Today, on Tu Bishvat, take a moment to truly see a tree. Look beyond its role as shade provider or landscape feature. Notice how its branches reach toward the sky in fractals, how its bark protects it from harsh elements, and how its roots spread unseen beneath the soil in complex networks. Consider how it’s part of a larger system—providing oxygen, storing carbon, creating soil, and sheltering countless organisms.

This is a day to acknowledge trees as resources and fellow travelers on Earth’s evolutionary journey. In a universe with mysteries stretching from the quantum to the cosmic scale, trees are a testament to life’s resilience and interconnectedness. This is a day to give thanks for this Universe, filled with so much hurt and sorrow, filled with infinite beauty and intimate connections.

Something Is Wrong

I do a lot of reading. Between novels, emails, subscriptions to news media, my beloved New York Times, and countless other options, I am in a constant state of perusal. The spigot is broken as the words cascade into my email and pile up on my desk. So much to read, so little time…

In addition to the almost limitless sources listed above, I receive a few listservs: daily, weekly, and monthly missives from various organizations. One of the ones I enjoy reading is from a Jewish spirituality institute with which I was involved. The institute has a special place in my heart. I gained some beautiful insights from the teachers and my fellow participants on various retreats and subsequent study sessions.

I remember returning from one of the retreats lit up with Jewish spiritual practice, infused with some new Jew-Bu (a mash-up of Jewish and Buddhist philosophies) vocabulary. I was asked to do a d’var Torah for the TBA executive committee, I think, and went on a Jewish mystical tangent. I sat down, feeling the afterglow of spiritual engagement, when Patti B. of blessed memory, leaned over the table and said to me, sotto voce, “What the hell was that all about?”

Yes, spirituality can be difficult to teach to those not entirely fluent in the language or concepts of the transcendent. It can sound fuzzy and utterly disconnected from the world. It sometimes seems naïve. Pejoratively, it is said to be “crunchy” and unsubstantial.

That’s why I take the time to read the listserv—it can be crunchy—and I like that. The concepts I learned 25 years ago fundamentally shaped my religious practice and theology. But I am a very different Jew, rabbi, and human now, so it’s not surprising that some of the things I read on the listserv are not in my spiritual realm.

This listserv is generally not a contentious space. We tend to be chill, spiritually adroit, and not prone to critique others. We learn early on that while each one of us has our own unique spiritual interiority, Jewish spirituality emphasizes finding the sacred within community rather than in isolation. Even private prayer is often phrased in the plural “we” rather than “I.” Mutual respect becomes a spiritual imperative.

So it struck me when there was a dust-up last week. A leading personality in the institute’s past and present, whom I will call Leah (I’m using a pseudonym to avoid any gossip), sent in an entry to the listserv. This is how it began: “Here’s what I know: Nothing is wrong. This physical dimension (out of the infinite dimensions of Being) is designed to facilitate the deepening of love and the awakening of Unity consciousness, often through challenge.” I understand Leah’s Buddhist teaching here. Don’t get confused by the specific shape of an argument or the actions of others. Don’t get sucked into foolishness or malicious arguments, or hateful rhetoric. Rise to the higher dimension of love, and don’t be misled by lower dimensional artifices. Don’t engage in the murky realm of self-interest.

But Leah’s transcendental configuration was not gratefully received by all. And let me be very quick to point out that Leah is only goodness, music, and life-affirmation. She was not seeking to hurt anyone. But there were a few responses that gutted me. They were from the families of trans kids who are beside themselves with worry and fear. Reading “nothing is wrong” is not only NOT comforting; they are words that feel ignorant and uninformed.

With this nothing is wrong logic, we could successfully argue that this planet Earth, this little blue marble, is one infinitesimally tiny, insignificant blur on the face of the Milky Way whose disappearance would mean nothing to the galaxy. But it would mean something to us. This is all we’ve got, so it all counts.

Nothing is wrong works in one’s spiritual practice. It’s a journal entry, a phrase to repeat while meditating. From 1000 miles up in space, nothing is wrong. From a dojo or a retreat center, nothing is wrong. But right here in this world so filled with woe and fear, a world where we aren’t sure what pages may be torn up, to say nothing is wrong feels dismissive and opaque. Something is wrong, and we’re the ones who have to try to fix it.

Tagged , , ,